The letter usually arrives long after the customer’s bankruptcy has faded from memory. It says your business received payments during the 90 days before the customer filed, and it demands that you return all of them, often within 30 days. You did the work, shipped the goods, and got paid what you were owed, so the demand feels absurd. It is also completely legal. Commercial litigation and insolvency lawyers handle these preference claims constantly, and they know how to cut a frightening number down to size.
Preference demands are rising along with business bankruptcies. Commercial Chapter 11 filings reached 4,589 in the first half of 2026, a 28% jump over the same period in 2025, according to Epiq AACER data. Every one of those cases can generate dozens or even hundreds of preference demands to vendors, suppliers, landlords, and service providers. Here is how these claims work and how to respond.
What Is a Preference Claim, Really?
Bankruptcy law tries to treat similar creditors equally. If a struggling company pays some vendors in full right before it files while others get nothing, the Bankruptcy Code lets the trustee pull those payments back into the estate and spread them across all creditors. That power comes from 11 U.S.C. § 547.
To recover a payment as a preference, the trustee generally must show that the payment:
- Went to or benefited a creditor
- Paid a debt the customer already owed before the payment
- Occurred while the customer was insolvent
- Happened within 90 days before the bankruptcy filing, or within one year if the creditor was an insider
- Gave the creditor more than it would have received in a Chapter 7 liquidation
The Bankruptcy Code presumes the debtor was insolvent during the 90 days before filing, so the trustee rarely has to prove that element unless you produce evidence to rebut it. The last element almost always favors the trustee too, since unsecured creditors in most bankruptcies recover only a small percentage of their claims. As a practical matter, the fight usually turns on the defenses.
How the Demand Letter Usually Arrives
In larger cases, the debtor’s plan often transfers preference claims to a liquidating trust, which hires a law firm or recovery specialist to pursue them. Those firms commonly send form letters to every vendor that received payments in the 90-day window, demanding the full total without crediting any defenses. Some letters offer a quick discount if you pay within a short deadline.
Timing matters on both sides. Under § 546(a), the trustee generally has two years from the bankruptcy filing to sue, which explains why demand letters often show up 18 months or more after the case began. Since the Small Business Reorganization Act of 2019, the trustee must also exercise reasonable due diligence and consider a creditor’s known or reasonably knowable defenses before bringing a preference action. A well-documented response that lays out your defenses puts real pressure on the trustee to justify going forward.
Ignoring the letter rarely helps. If the trustee files an adversary proceeding and you do not respond, the court can enter a default judgment for the full amount. In addition, § 502(d) allows the estate to object to your own claim in the bankruptcy until you return any preference, which can block your recovery on unpaid invoices.
Defenses That Reduce or Eliminate Liability
The Bankruptcy Code gives creditors several defenses, and most businesses qualify for at least one of them. Commercial litigation and insolvency lawyers typically analyze all of them together, because each one can carve off a different slice of the demand.
Ordinary Course of Business
A trustee cannot recover payments made in the ordinary course of business between the parties, or according to ordinary business terms in the industry. Creditors usually prove this defense by comparing payment timing during the 90-day window with the historical relationship. If the customer always paid in about 45 days and kept paying in about 45 days, the defense looks strong. If the customer suddenly paid in 120 days after pressure from your collections team, it gets harder.
Subsequent New Value
If you shipped goods or provided services on credit after receiving a payment, that new value can offset the earlier payment. For vendors with an active, rolling account, this defense alone can eliminate a large share of the claim.
Contemporaneous Exchange
Payments that both parties intended as a simultaneous exchange for new value, such as cash on delivery or payment at pickup, generally fall outside preference law.
The Small-Transfer Threshold
In cases filed on or after April 1, 2025, a trustee cannot recover transfers that total less than $8,575 to a single creditor on non-consumer debts. The 2025 Federal Register adjustment raised that figure from $7,575, and it applies to the combined value of all transfers, not each payment individually.
Building Your Record Before You Respond
The strongest preference defenses come from your own accounting system. Before you respond to a demand, gather:
- Every invoice, payment date, check number, and wire record for at least 12 months before the filing, and longer if the relationship goes back further
- Shipping records and delivery confirmations for goods supplied after each payment
- Collection notes, emails, and call logs that show how payment timing changed, if at all
- Any credit limits, holds, or new terms you imposed during the 90-day window
With that data, counsel can calculate average days-to-pay before and during the preference period and apply new value credits payment by payment. That analysis usually becomes the backbone of the response letter and any settlement negotiation.
When the relationship with the customer was short or irregular, counsel may also gather industry data, such as credit agency reports or trade association surveys, to support the industry-terms version of the ordinary course defense.
Be careful with early informal communications. A quick email to the trustee saying the customer paid late because you threatened to cut them off can undercut your ordinary course defense before you have a chance to frame it.
How Commercial Litigation and Insolvency Lawyers Negotiate These Claims
Most preference claims settle. The real question is how much. Counsel who understands both commercial litigation and bankruptcy procedure can present your defenses in a way that shows the trustee its realistic recovery after litigation costs. Many trustees accept a fraction of the original demand once they see a documented defense analysis.
Venue and procedure matter as well. Smaller claims may have to proceed in your home district rather than in the bankruptcy court where the case sits, and some courts send preference lawsuits to mediation programs. An attorney that knows how business disputes play out in court, like an experienced business litigation attorney in Houston, can judge when to push back hard and when to settle.
Settlement terms deserve as much attention as the number itself. A good settlement agreement resolves every avoidance claim the estate holds against your business, not just the preference count, and addresses whether you keep your general unsecured claim for any unpaid invoices. Payment timing, mutual releases, and court approval requirements all belong in the negotiation.
Other Claims That Can Arrive With a Preference Demand
Trustees sometimes pair preference claims with fraudulent transfer counts, especially when the payments went to a related company, involved unusual terms, or exceeded the value of what the creditor provided. Under 11 U.S.C. § 548 and Texas fraudulent transfer law, a trustee can challenge transfers made for less than reasonably equivalent value while the debtor was insolvent, and those lookback periods run well beyond 90 days. Ordinary trade vendors who delivered fair value at market prices usually have strong answers to these claims, but the response needs to address them directly rather than treating the letter as a simple preference demand.
Setoff and recoupment can matter too. If you owed the debtor money at the same time it owed you, through rebates, credits, or amounts due under a related contract, those mutual obligations may reduce your exposure or affect your claim. These issues come up often in distribution, construction, and service relationships, and they deserve attention before anyone agrees on a settlement number.
Protecting Payments on Future Accounts
Preference risk starts long before a bankruptcy filing. A few habits help reduce exposure on future accounts:
- Watch for warning signs such as slower payments, partial payments, requests for extended terms, or new lawsuits against a customer
- Use deposits, letters of credit, and personal guarantees for larger or riskier accounts
- Keep payment terms consistent, since sudden changes during a customer’s decline can weaken the ordinary course defense
- Move to cash terms when a customer’s condition deteriorates, which supports a contemporaneous exchange defense
- Remember that goods delivered within 20 days before a bankruptcy filing can support a priority administrative claim under § 503(b)(9)
Businesses that sell on credit benefit from regular legal review of their terms, guarantees, and collection practices. That kind of ongoing guidance is exactly what outside general counsel services are built for.
Conclusion
A preference demand opens a negotiation; it does not set a final bill. The trustee carries real burdens, the Bankruptcy Code gives creditors meaningful defenses, and documented responses regularly reduce these claims to a fraction of the opening number. Commercial litigation and insolvency lawyers who build the defenses early, protect your claim against the estate, and know when to push back put your business in the strongest position to keep the money it already earned.
Talk to MPP Legal Before You Respond
MPP Legal defends Texas businesses against preference and fraudulent transfer claims in bankruptcy courts across the country. Our attorneys are admitted in every bankruptcy court in Texas and have defended preference claims in Texas, Delaware, and Illinois for clients ranging from community banks to Fortune 500 companies. Our commercial litigation attorney team and insolvency litigation practice work together to analyze your defenses, negotiate with trustees, and litigate when necessary. If you received a preference demand letter, contact MPP Legal before you respond.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why am I being asked to return money a bankrupt customer paid me?
Bankruptcy law lets a trustee recover certain payments made in the 90 days before a filing so that similar creditors receive equal treatment. The demand does not mean you did anything wrong. It means the payment fits the basic definition of a preference, and you may still have defenses that reduce or eliminate it.
How long does a bankruptcy trustee have to file a preference lawsuit?
A trustee generally has two years from the date of the bankruptcy filing to sue under 11 U.S.C. § 546(a), with a possible extension if the court appoints a trustee late in that period. That timeline explains why many demand letters arrive more than a year after the customer files.
What is the ordinary course of business defense?
This defense protects payments made in the ordinary course of business between you and the customer, or according to ordinary business terms in your industry. Creditors usually prove it by showing that payment timing during the 90-day window matched the historical relationship or industry norms.
Can I negotiate a preference demand without going to court?
Yes. Most preference claims settle before or shortly after a lawsuit begins. A response letter that documents your defenses and payment history often persuades the trustee to accept a fraction of the original demand, especially since the trustee must consider known defenses before suing.
Is there a minimum amount for a preference claim?
Yes. In bankruptcy cases filed on or after April 1, 2025, a trustee cannot recover total transfers of less than $8,575 to a single creditor on non-consumer debts. Separate venue rules may also require smaller claims to proceed in the creditor’s home district.

Haven Massey is a Partner at Marshall Presley & Pipal PLLC, focusing on construction law, commercial real estate, business litigation, and corporate transactions. One of fewer than five attorneys in Texas to hold dual Board Certifications in both Construction Law and Commercial Real Estate Law, Haven brings rare depth to every matter he handles. A cum laude Texas A&M graduate and former Aggie football letterman, he combines the discipline of an athlete with the strategic judgment of a seasoned litigator recognized by Best Lawyers in America from 2021–2025.


